Thursday, July 23, 2009

Anna, Stanislav, Natalia: Who's Next?

"Grozny was a wasteland, physically, morally, psychologically. Ms. Estemirova was almost otherworldly. She inhabited a separate Chechnya, a region where dignity might prevail." (CJ Chivers)

When I read last week of the brutal death of Natalia (Natasha) Estemirova I was transported back to the northern Caucasus and the violence that still breathes its stinking breath there, gloating in its own impunity, and stalking protectors of the unprotected.

My mind, without prompting, immediately conjured up the terrible scene that likely unfolded for Natasha. The early morning snatch which would have been clinical and swift leaving her in no doubt that her hour had come. The calculating brutality as she was dragged from from the car, the pumping of bullet after bullet into her head and torso as she lay there defenceless.

In those last seconds did she regret her dedication to human rights? Did she doubt if it had all been worth while? Did she fear for her young daughter’s future? The thugs that pulled the trigger wanted silence. It is in their interests to spread a cancer of fear through torture, abuse, crime and the cold blooded murder of innocents. To rid the area of neutral observers is the tactic.

Just as it had been in Novi Atagi, Chechnya, back in 1996.

For aid workers of a certain generation the name ‘Chechnya’ can have ominous undertones. It was here on the 17th of December 1996 that six Red Cross workers were killed as they slept in the bedrooms of the hospital they worked in. A hospital dedicated to tending the war wounded victims of Chechnya's conflict.

The six were assassinated by gunmen who still roam free and unpunished. I had just joined our team in the Russian Federation at this time and the trauma that it sent through the aid community, but in particular our organization, was deep and lasting.

Essentially, overnight, everything changed. We went from an organization that embraced risk and excelled at operating in war-torn regions, assisting and doing our best to protect the victims of conflict, to an organization that was forced to put its own safety first – even when that meant abandoning conflict-ridden communities desperately in need of an independent organization to advocate in thier interests in the uphill struggle to reduce the suffering of war.

Tributes followed by Impunity

The tributes that poured in for Natasha from her Chechen neighbours, from her human rights colleagues all over the world, and from the many journalists she had come to know, is a testimony to the remarkable woman that she surely was.

In one such tribute, from journalist CJ Chivers of the New York Times, who knows the region better than most, he summed up Chechnya in a few words: "Chechnya is a tiny spot on Russia’s big map, home to only several hundred thousand souls. But its past two decades offered lenses into factors driving modern war: nationalism, oil, religious intolerance, racism, tribalism, blood codes that demand revenge, irregular fighters and ill-disciplined conventional units, outright banditry, poverty, official corruption and, for good measure, traveling Islamic mercenaries and a government rooted in a personality cult."

Estemirova's death is the latest in a series of attacks and murders of human rights workers seeking justice and accountability for violations, particularly in Chechnya. In January, Umar Israilov was shot and killed in broad daylight in Vienna, where he was living in exile. Less than a week later, Stanislav Markelov, a prominent human rights lawyer who represented numerous victims of human rights abuses in Chechnya, was shot to death on the street after leaving a Moscow news conference. Anastasiya Baburova, a journalist who was with him, was also killed. No arrests have been made in either case.

Most famously, investigative reporter Anna Politkovskaya was shot dead outside her Moscow apartment in October 2006, after writing numerous articles critical of the human rights situation in Chechnya.

Tanya Lokshina, a colleague of Natasha, recalls how she came to town for her friend Markelov’s funeral earlier this year : "We sat at my kitchen table talking into the wee hours about Markelov and Politkovskaya and speculating about who would be next. Now I know."

Open Season on Human Rights workers in Chechnya?

In an article Tanya wrote for the Washington Post she says: "We don't know who pulled the trigger on the gun that killed Natasha, but responsibility for the climate of impunity in Chechnya goes straight to Moscow."

These sentiments were echoed by Kenneth Roth, director of Human Rights Watch: "The Russian authorities should take every possible step to bring Natalia Estemirova's killers to justice. It seems to be open season on anyone trying to highlight the appalling human rights abuses in Chechnya. It's high time the Russian government acted to stop these killings and prosecute those responsible."

If Natasha did have doubts as she faced her assassins I hope that time will prove that its not so easy to quench the flame of humanity. Natasha's dignified, selfless and courageous fight for the rights of the voiceless many cannot be in vain.

I leave the final word to her friend, journalist CJ Chivers: "She was, improbably, a one-woman parallel government, providing services that the real government was unwilling to offer. She found the incarcerated. She hunted for hidden graves. She built cases against perpetrators, even when she found, as she often did, that they wore government uniforms."

(The title of this post is taken from a banner at the Moscow march held in honour of Natasha and in rememberance of her fallen colleagues).

Also - worth a read from the Guardian UK.



  1. .بسم الله الرحمان الرحيم
    Bonjour tout la monde.

    Qui a tué Anna Politkovskaïa ?

    Le président tchétchène Ramzan Kadyrov connaît la vérité de meurtriers de la journaliste Anna Politkovskaïa, allez lui poser la question. R. Kadyrov est un homme d’état dure,mais ce n’est pas lui qui est derrière cet assassinat. Enfin, R. Kadyrov a fait tout ce qui peut pour empêcher l’assassinat de la journaliste courageuse Anna Politkovskaïa,c’est pour cela qu’il la renfermer ‘cher lui’ pendant quelque jour, les assassins étaient derrière elle ce temps là. Le président R.Kadyrov,qui ne veut pas risquer sa propre vie,ni mois son poste pour dénoncer les assassins, se voit aussi menacé de mort face à une ’organisation criminelle ‘ qui viens de naître en Russie et que personne ne peut contrôler ,même Le président de la Russie Dmitry Medvedev. Cette Organisation criminelle,que personne ne peut arrêter,se cache derrière le conflit Russie- tchétchènie -le Caucase russe pour assassiner tout ceux et celles qui cherchent la vérité et défendent l’être humain quelque soit sa couleur de peau, sa religion ou ses origines.
    avant de terminer,'cadet et ses deux 'camarades'(Alexandre) Prilepine et (Valeri) Minine (policiers de Khanty-Mansiisk) toujours en liberté,appartiennent bien à "L'organisation criminelle"avec d'autres cadres hautement placés, alors il est temps de revoir du coté de Serguei Lapine(si ne change pas encore ses papiers d'identité) et ses deux complices qui representent un réel danger pour la vie de toute personne cherchant derrière eux ,voir même pensant à le faire.
    Un conseil : quand vous enquêtez la dessus mettez des lunettes incassable.

    Stanislav Markelov et Anastassia Babourova ?

    ils étaient deux assassins professionnels sur une motocyclette,ils avaient pour mission d’exécuter Me Markelov,ces assassins se sont arrêtés au coin de la rue pour ne pas attirer d’attention,le premier tueur est descendu,poursuivit Markelov et le tua, Anastassia l’aperçoit aussitôt le poursuit et parvient à le neutraliser, à ce moment là, le second criminel intervient et tire sur la jeune femme,puis les deux assassins montent sur la moto, mettent leurs casques et quittent à grande vitesse le lieu du crime.

    Assassinat de Natalia Esterimova ?

    Les assassins voulaient kidnapper sa fille,la violer devant les yeux de sa mère. ils voulaient les détruire toutes les deux. pour ‘L’organisation criminelle’ ,Les exécuteurs ont ‘mal réagit’ en tuant Natalia Esterimova « paisiblement ».
    conseil personnel: ne suivez pas le même chemin que Natalia Esterimova, vous etes encore jeune .

    ces quatre Assassinat sont ils liés ?

    la réponse est oui. La vérité a toujours un témoin ,chose que les assassins ignorent.

    Pour bien comprendre ce qui se passe, La recherche philosophique-scientifique- islamique:, fait lumière sur une nouvelle théorie ‘la théorie de l’autre’, théorie qui nous a beaucoup aider pour trouver ces informations nouvelles.

    Signé : Aicha benmoussa ben isti .

  2. Hey – great blog, just looking around some blogs, seems a really nice platform you are using. I’m currently using WordPress for a few of my blogs but looking to change one of them over to a platform similar to yours as a trial run. Anything in particular you would recommend about it?